House votes for fourth time as Republicans fight over

Key events

Fourth vote begins…

House votes for fourth time as Republicans fight over

Martin Pengelly

Pete Aguilar of California rises to nominate for speaker Hakeem Jeffries of New York, the new Democratic leader in the House.

There is a new email from the Democratic whip, meanwhile, advising members of what we all know by now: “If the speaker is elected and receives the oath of office, they will administer the oath to members and delegates. If no candidate receives 218 votes, the House will continue voting until a speaker is elected or the House agrees to adjourn.”

A Democratic email.
A Democratic email. Photograph: Katherine Clark

And then comes Chip Roy of Texas, one of the leaders of the rebel Republicans, who nominates Byron Donalds of Florida for speaker.

Donalds is the Republican who switched his vote yesterday, in the third vote, to back Jim Jordan of Ohio instead of Kevin McCarthy.

Roy notes that this is the first time two Black Americans have been placed into nomination for speaker (Jeffries being the first Black party leader in Congress). Then he talks for quite a long time about why he is leading opposition to McCarthy. As per yesterday, Roy appeals to the spirit of the American people, to democracy, and so forth.

The reading clerk will call the role. So here goes…

Republicans set up fourth vote

House votes for fourth time as Republicans fight over

Martin Pengelly

Kevin McCarthy, wearing a dark suit and a muted tie, is on the floor and has been talking with members of his caucus including Tom Cole, a veteran from Oklahoma.

Here we go for a fourth vote, with the nomination of McCarthy for speaker of the House and a round of applause from his loyalists.

Mike Gallagher of Wisconsin, nominating McCarthy, glories in the undoubted fact that “democracy is messy” and “the American people are in charge”. Republicans stand to applaud that line.

Chip Roy of Texas, a rebel ringleader, listens intently nearby.

House votes for fourth time as Republicans fight over

Martin Pengelly

Elise Stefanik of New York, a member of Republican leadership, begins by making a point of order, that a quorum – sufficient attendance for a vote – is not present.

And so a count begins, to see if at least 218 members are present, the total Kevin McCarthy needs to become speaker. Discussion groups form, the C-SPAN cameras showing Democrats and Republicans clustering and chatting around the ornate chamber.

The chair counts 351 members, Cheryl Johnson, the House clerk, says – so that’s enough to begin with.

House reconvenes

House votes for fourth time as Republicans fight over

Martin Pengelly

The House chamber has reconvened, the gavel struck. The daily prayer is being offered.

Before members filed back into the chamber, Kevin McCarthy voiced confidence that he will ultimately win the 218 votes needed to capture the gavel.

“I think we’ll find our way to get there,” McCarthy told reporters on Tuesday. “This is a healthy debate. It might not happen on the day we want it, but it’s going to happen.”

Maybe, but it could certainly take a while.

There is reporting out there that Republicans could try to vote to adjourn immediately today, thus delaying a fourth vote on the speakership.

The Democratic whip, Katherine Clark, has told her party to vote no if an adjournment is sought:

An email from the Democratic whip.
An email from the Democratic whip. Photograph: Email

Earlier, Pete Aguilar, a senior member of Democratic leadership, indicated his party wants to get things done.

“We don’t have status as members until we organize,” the Californian told reporters, “and that’s unfortunately as a result of this Republican chaos. There will come a point where other things are impacted: committees can’t hire their staff members, as well, because there are no committee chairs and ranking members.

“This is this is a crisis of the Congress and it’s a crisis at the hands of the Republican dysfunction. ”

House votes for fourth time as Republicans fight over

Martin Pengelly

As the resumption of events on the House floor approaches – it’s set for 12pm ET – it seems worth a look at how Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez has explained why she was seen talking on the floor yesterday with the far-right Republicans Matt Gaetz and Paul Gosar, the latter once censured for tweeting video depicting him slashing her in the neck with a sword.

Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez.
Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez. Photograph: Mandel Ngan/AFP/Getty Images

Gosar, from Arizona, was among 20 Republicans opposing Kevin McCarthy’s bid for speaker. So was Gaetz of Florida, a ringleader of the anti-McCarthy rebels.

Ocasio-Cortez told the Intercept her conversation with Gaetz was a “fact-check”.

“McCarthy was suggesting he could get Dems to walk away to lower his threshold,” Ocasio-Cortez said. “And I fact-checked and said absolutely not.”

Ocasio-Cortez said she discussed adjournment strategy with Gosar.

“Some of us in the House of Representatives are independent in certain ways from our party,” she told MSNBC. “And … these machinations are happening on the floor.

“And sometimes the leadership of your party, in this case, the Republican party, will be making claims in order to try to twist arms and get people in line. And a lot of times, information and truth is currency.

“So sometimes to be able to fact-check some of the claims that McCarthy is making, whether Democrats are going to defect or not, etc, is important in order to keep him honest and to keep people honest in general.”

Full story:

How many times can the House vote for speaker?

House votes for fourth time as Republicans fight over

Martin Pengelly

… is a question many people are asking today, as the resumption of formalities (and hostilities) in the House approaches.

The short answer: as many times as it takes for a candidate to gain a simple majority.

The slightly longer answer … follows, from a Q&A about the whole sorry situation we have launched today:

The last time the House did not elect a speaker on the first ballot was 1923, when the election stretched for nine votes.

Republicans had the majority, over Democrats by 18 seats. The GOP named Frederick Gillett of Massachusetts to the position but several other candidates, including a Democrat, received votes during roll call.

This resulted in a series of ballots over three days before the majority leader, Nicholas Longworth of Ohio, held an emergency meeting with those opposing. Their concern, similarly to those issued against Kevin McCarthy of California this year, was over rules changes they believed deserved a fair hearing. Longworth obliged. The next day, Gillett got the 215 votes he needed.

There is also the example of 1855-56, in the years of division over slavery that preceded the civil war. Then, with the Republican party newly emerged as an anti-slavery force, it took 133 ballots over nearly two months to elect a speaker. Eventually, Nathaniel Banks of Massachusetts – a nativist Know-Nothing, no less – got the job.

Here’s the full explainer:

Mike Pence endorses McCarthy

Mike Pence has publicly supported McCarthy as House Speaker, with the House set to meet for a vote in less than an hour.

Calling McCarthy his “friend”, Pence urged GOP members via Twitter to support McCarthy and lead the House to bring about a “Great American Comeback”.

Urging Every Republican in @HouseGOP to support my friend, Kevin McCarthy as the next Speaker of the House. @GOPLeader‘s Leadership & Vision led to The New Republican Majority & I know Speaker McCarthy will lead the House to begin a Great American Comeback!🇺🇸

— Mike Pence (@Mike_Pence) January 4, 2023

It appears Pence and Trump are on the same page, attempting to sway the coalition of 20 Republicans who remain staunchly opposed to McCarthy’s election.

US Capitol police officer Michael Fanone, who testified to the January 6 committee, visited McCarthy’s office today to highlight McCarthy’s failure to secure his House speaker vote.

While posing outside of McCarthy’s office, Fanone said he visited McCarthy to “rub it in”, referring to McCarthy’s election failure.

“I heard he was having some trouble … I just came here to rub it in,” Fanone told reporters.

United States Capitol Police officer Michael Fanone who testified before the Jan. 6 cmte poses outside the speaker’s office where McCarthy is: “I heard he was having some trouble … I just came here to rub it in,” he says. pic.twitter.com/eeyc7USAwx

— Mica Soellner (@MicaSoellnerDC) January 4, 2023

Meanwhile, Democrats are celebrating the expected election of Hakeem Jeffries, who will be the first Black lawmaker to lead any political party.

Democrats have been united on Jeffries, amid Republicans failure to secure their own leader.

From US Representative-elect Katherine Clark of Massachusetts:

Day 2 of the 118th Congress: @HouseDemocrats stand united in fighting for progress. Republicans are fighting each other.

— Katherine Clark (@RepKClark) January 4, 2023

In a brief interview on Wednesday, Donald Trump reiterated his support for McCarthy and encouraged GOP members to “make a deal” to secure McCarthy’s election.

While speaking with Punchbowl News, Trump said that McCarthy opponents needed to work with McCarthy and elect him as Speaker, adding that he has been trying to corral much needed votes for McCarthy ahead of today’s scheduled House speaker vote.

From Trump:

I think that it’s time now to make a deal to get down to work and they have a lot of work to do. We had a great victory…. And I think that it’s time now for the Republicans to get on with it.

Biden: House speaker debacle ’embarrassing’, ‘not a good look’

Joe Biden has commented on the House speaker chaos, calling the failure of Republicans to choose a speaker “not a good look” for the country.

While leaving the White House to Kentucky for his speech on the infrastructure bill, Biden told reporters that the failure of Republicans to elect a House speaker is “embarrassing”, stating that the debacle is “not his problem”.

“I hope they get their act together,” said Biden.

President Biden on GOP’s inability to settle on a speaker — “It’s not a good look. It’s not a good thing. This is the United States of America and I hope they get their act together.” Biden is heading to Kentucky today where he’ll appear w/McConnell to promote infra law.

— Nancy Cook (@nancook) January 4, 2023

Mitch McConnell has remained relatively quiet on the lack of a Republican House speaker, telling reporters yesterday after the first failed vote that he was “pulling” for Kevin McCarthy.

Following his own re-election as Senate minority leader, McConnell was traveling on Wednesday to his home state, Kentucky, to join Joe Biden for a bipartisan touting of the infrastructure bill.

Senate Republican leadership have expressed their concern over the House speaker debacle as the 12pm voice vote looms.

West Virginia senator Shelley Moore Capito called the Speaker proceedings a “circular fire squad,” adding to Politico that she is glad to no longer be a House member:

The unsteadiness I see over there [in the House] concerns me. We get the majority, and then we start a circular firing squad…

I just hope they can overcome the dysfunction,” she added of her former House colleagues…And also, I’m very glad I’m not back in the House.

Read the full article here.

Late Tuesday, opponents and supporters of McCarthy met for hours, reported Politico, in an attempt to figure out a path towards electing a House speaker.

The meeting adjourned with limited progress, with a subsequent meeting scheduled ahead of today’s 12pm vote cancelled.

From Politico reporter Sarah Ferris:

From Hill reporter Mychael Schnell, with comments from House member Chip Roy:

Leaving the Capitol tonight, @chiproytx told a few reporters that the GOP conference meeting this morning “was a complete disaster and it hardened people and expanded the no votes.”

“The numbers exploded out of the gate after that conference meeting,” he added.

— Mychael Schnell (@mychaelschnell) January 4, 2023

Trump did not communicate with some House members who opposed McCarthy before posting his endorsement.

From Washington Examiner reporter Juliegrace Brufke:

“Trump’s staff just sent his truth social post out to all of us,” one member tells me.

— Juliegrace Brufke (@juliegraceb) January 4, 2023

From Politico reporter Olivia Beavers:

NEWS: Two of the 20 House Rs who voted against McCarthy tell me they haven’t heard directly from Trump re. the speakership race — so far.

One says they haven’t heard much at all from McCarthy’s camp/allies.

— Olivia Beavers (@Olivia_Beavers) January 4, 2023

Even with Trump’s public support of McCarthy, opponents of the House Speaker nominee do not seem swayed by the endorsement.

Several have taken to social media to share their disapproval, accusing the McCarthy of “squatting” in the Speaker office after losing the vote multiple times.

Late Tuesday, Florida representative Matt Gaetz shared a letter he wrote to the Architect of the Capitol, with Gaetz accusing McCarthy of occupying the Speaker of the House office despite losing the vote several times.

The Speaker of the House Office in the Capitol is currently being occupied by Kevin McCarthy.

Kevin McCarthy is not the Speaker of the House. He lost 3 consecutive votes today.

I’m demanding answers from the Architect of the Capitol. pic.twitter.com/AIZ8bFks6W

— Rep. Matt Gaetz (@RepMattGaetz) January 4, 2023

Gaetz’ letter was retweeted by Arizona representative Andy Biggs, who also voted against McCarthy’s selection and accused McCarthy of “squatting” in said office.

Trump backs McCarthy: ‘Vote for Kevin, close the deal’

Good morning, Guardian readers!

Yesterday, Kevin McCarthy failed to secure enough votes to be the GOP House speaker, the first time in 100 years where a nominee hasn’t won enough votes during the first ballot.

But, to push back against his mostly hard-right opponents, McCarthy has touted Donald Trump’s support of his House speakership, with the former president publicly backing McCarthy’s leadership.

In what has been called “the most humiliating day of his political career”, McCarthy faces an uphill battle to secure enough votes, as the House is set to reconvene for a voice vote at 12pm ET.

Twenty House members blocked McCarthy’s election, the majority being far-right members who also denied the legitimacy of the 2020 election, reported the New York Times.

But McCarthy has been quick to confirm that he has the support of Trump, telling reporters late Tuesday that Trump “wants to see the Republicans united to be able to accomplish the exact things we said we’d do”, and adding that he has no plans to drop out.

Meanwhile, Trump also rallied for McCarthy on social media, posting on his Truth Social account:

Some really good conversations took place last night, and it’s now time for all of our GREAT Republican House Members to VOTE FOR KEVIN, CLOSE THE DEAL, TAKE THE VICTORY, & WATCH CRAZY NANCY PELOSI FLY BACK HOME TO A VERY BROKEN CALIFORNIA,THE ONLY SPEAKER IN U.S. HISTORY TO HAVE LOST THE “HOUSE” TWICE! REPUBLICANS, DO NOT TURN A GREAT TRIUMPH INTO A GIANT & EMBARRASSING DEFEAT. IT’S TIME TO CELEBRATE, YOU DESERVE IT. Kevin McCarthy will do a good job, and maybe even a GREAT JOB – JUST WATCH!

We will be bringing you the latest updates surrounding McCarthy’s bid and Republican reaction, so stay tuned!